Peer review process
To ensure an objective and purposeful review process, the journal follows these steps:
First: Selection of Reviewers
Second: The Review Process
first : election of Reviewer
A core responsibility of the editorial board is to select reviewers whose expertise aligns with the subject matter of the submitted research.
Ethical principles governing the selection of reviewers include transparency, impartiality, subject-matter expertise, confidentiality, and research integrity.
Second: The Review Process
The journal employs a rigorous procedure that begins upon receipt of a submission, proceeds through an evaluation phase, and concludes with a final decision: either acceptance for publication or rejection.
Once a submission is received, the editorial board forwards it to reviewers while maintaining strict confidentiality; the reviewers are not informed of the author’s identity.
What are the possible outcomes of the review process?
A. Acceptance for publication without the need for any revisions.
B. Acceptance for publication, contingent upon revisions (whether minor or substantive).
C. Rejection, with an explanation provided for the decision.
How is the author notified of the review outcome? The author is informed of the results via email. The outcome may be acceptance for publication without revisions, acceptance pending revisions, or rejection. If revisions are requested, the author is expected to address the reviewers' suggestions and resubmit the work for further evaluation. However, the implementation of these revisions is not strictly mandatory. The author may provide a response supported by robust scientific evidence. Once the research paper is accepted for publication, the author receives a formal acceptance letter from the journal.
The paper undergoes a rigorous peer-review process and a comprehensive evaluation, which typically takes between one and a half to two months before a final decision regarding its acceptance is reached.