Editor's Guidelines
Editors are responsible for managing the manuscript review process, providing recommendations regarding acceptance or rejection, and encouraging the submission of high-quality articles. The following guidelines for editors are based on the "Code of Conduct and Best Practice Guidelines for Journal Editors" issued by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
-Selection of Reviewers:
1- Editors are responsible for the careful selection of appropriate reviewers for the research papers they handle.
2- Reviewers must possess the expertise to evaluate the work accurately and must have no conflicts of interest that could prevent them from providing an objective assessment.
3- Editors should select at least two reviewers to provide expert opinions. If a reviewer consistently submits evaluations that are rude, of poor quality, or delayed, the editor should cease using them.
4- When seeking new reviewers, editors should not rely solely on their personal networks; rather, they should explore a variety of sources, such as bibliographic databases.
- The Review Process:
1- Editors must ensure that all research papers assigned to them are processed in a timely manner, with an initial decision reached within three months.
2- Editors should make every effort to handle all research papers assigned to them, regardless of their specific area of expertise. A paper should only be returned to the section editor for reassignment in exceptional cases. Section editors aim to distribute research papers appropriately, ensuring an equitable division of the workload among editorial board members. Occasionally, it may be unavoidable... ...assigning a manuscript to an editor whose expertise does not precisely align with the subject matter.
3- Even when a decision is entirely consistent with the reviewers' comments, editors must provide written feedback to the authors. In such cases, a brief summary of the reviewers' comments consisting of one or two sentences is sufficient.
4- Editors must be prepared to provide a compelling justification for any significant deviation from established peer-review procedures.
1- Before assigning a review task, editors should require reviewers to disclose any potential conflicts of interest. Furthermore, editors must carefully evaluate the performance of reviewers and take the necessary measures to ensure that a high standard of quality is maintained.
2- Editors should encourage reviewers to flag any ethical concerns or potential instances of research or publication misconductsuch as the use of unethical research methodologies, data manipulation, or the inappropriate presentation of findings that may arise in the submitted work.
3- Reviewers should assess the originality of the submitted research while remaining vigilant for any signs of redundant publication or plagiarism.
- Decisions:
1- Editors' recommendations regarding the acceptance or rejection of a manuscript for publication must be based on both the reviewers' (peers') assessments and the editor's own evaluation of the work’s significance, originality, and clarity, as well as the soundness of the study and its alignment with the journal's scope.
2- If a submitted manuscript does not meet the journal's standards, editors are advised to recommend its rejection. immediately.
3- Editors should exercise caution when considering the reversal of a prior decision to accept a research paper or study; such action should only be taken if fundamental issues are discovered. Regarding decisions made by previous editors:
4- New editors should refrain from overturning prior publication decisions unless they uncover serious problems within the submitted research paper.
5- In cases involving suspected misconduct or disputes regarding authorship, it is the responsibility of the editors to notify the editor-in-chief or the publisher and to address these matters in accordance with established procedures.