Publication Ethics

 

Publishing research in the journal Masarat for Legal Sciences is part of an ongoing process of knowledge development and a clear reflection of the quality of legal research. It also serves as a testament to the support provided by researchers and the institutions to which they belong. Masarat is committed to the highest standards of scholarly review and professional peer evaluation. Consequently, all parties involved in the journal’s production—authors, reviewers, and editors—are expected to uphold the utmost professionalism and adhere to the ethical standards required of every participant in the publication process.

The Iraqi Association for Legal Sciences, as the owner of the journal, is committed to exercising due diligence at every stage of the publication process. All research submitted to the journal undergoes a rigorous peer-review process and strict editorial scrutiny before being accepted for publication.

Editorial decisions are made with complete independence, free from any influence by advertisements or other sources of commercial revenue. Furthermore, the editorial board reserves the right to collaborate with other journals or publishing houses whenever such cooperation serves the editorial process.

First: Authors’ Responsibilities

·  Standards for Presenting Research:

Authors must ensure the originality of the work they submit, provide an accurate description of the research conducted, and offer an objective discussion of its significance. Additionally, the research should include sufficient detail and references to enable others to utilize, review, or replicate the work. Articles and research papers must be professional and objective in nature, with precise documentation of all data and cited material. The journal may request that authors provide the raw data from their research for review purposes, and authors are expected to retain such data for a reasonable period following publication.

·  Originality and Plagiarism:

Authors are responsible for ensuring the originality of the work they submit. If the work or phrasing of others is used, it must be clearly acknowledged and properly documented. Plagiarism can take various forms—ranging from claiming authorship of work written by others, to incorporating substantial portions of another’s work without appropriate citation, or presenting the research findings of others as one’s own. Plagiarism, in any form, is considered unethical and unacceptable in academic publishing.

·  Multiple, Redundant, or Concurrent Publication:

Authors may not submit the same research to more than one journal or primary publishing platform; submitting the same work to multiple journals simultaneously is considered unethical and unacceptable in academic publishing. Furthermore, as a general rule, authors may not submit previously published research for consideration by another journal.

·  Citing Sources:

Authors must always appropriately acknowledge the work of others that has influenced the content or development of their own research. The use of information obtained through private channels—such as conversations, correspondence, or discussions with third parties—is prohibited without obtaining explicit written permission from the source. Similarly, information obtained through confidential services—such as the peer review of research manuscripts or the evaluation of grant applications—may not be used without the explicit written consent of the author(s) to whom the work in question belongs.

 

 

·  Authorship:

Intellectual property rights are reserved for those who have made a substantial contribution to the planning, design, or execution of a study, or to the interpretation of its results. Therefore, all individuals who have made a significant contribution to a research project must be included as authors. Furthermore, any involvement by other parties in the technical aspects of the research should be acknowledged, or those individuals should be listed as contributors.

The corresponding author must ensure that all contributors have reviewed the final version of the article and consented to its publication.

·  Significant Errors in Published Work:

When an author discovers a significant error or inaccuracy in their own published work, they are obligated to notify the editor or publisher immediately and cooperate in retracting or correcting the work. If a third party discovers a significant error, the author is required to retract or correct the work, or provide evidence supporting the validity of the original research.

Second: Responsibilities of Editors

·  Publication Decisions:

The editor-in-chief of the journal is responsible for the decision to publish a research paper. This decision must be based on the significance of the work to readers and the consent of the authors. The editor must adhere to the journal’s policies and legal requirements regarding copyright, defamation, and plagiarism. The editor may consult with others to reach this decision.

·  Fair Review:

Editors must evaluate research papers and studies based solely on their intellectual content, without regard to the author’s origin, gender, religious beliefs, race, nationality, or political views.

 

·  Confidentiality:

The editor-in-chief and members of the editorial board must not share any information regarding a submitted research paper or study with anyone other than the author, reviewers, evaluators, and editorial advisors.

·  Disclosure and Conflicts of Interest:

Editors must not use any part of a submitted research paper or study for their own research without the explicit written consent of the author. Editors must maintain the confidentiality of any unique information or ideas obtained through the review process and must not use them for personal gain. Editors must recuse themselves from handling manuscripts where a conflict of interest exists such as instances involving competitive or collaborative relationships, or other connections to the authors or relevant organizations. If a conflict of interest is discovered after publication, it must be disclosed, and appropriate corrective measures such as issuing a correction—must be taken. Reviews of supplementary materials must be conducted within the context of the review of the main article. Supplements must be accepted based on their academic value and the interests of the readers, free from the influence of commercial considerations.

·  Addressing Complaints and Cooperating in Investigations

Editors must take appropriate action when ethical complaints are raised regarding a submitted manuscript or a published study. Such actions include contacting the author(s) of the work, carefully reviewing the complaints and allegations, and potentially reaching out to the institutions affiliated with the research. If a complaint is substantiated, the journal must issue corrections, retractions, or expressions of concern, as appropriate. Any unethical conduct discovered in published research must be addressed, even if it comes to light long after the work has been published.

 

·  Procedures Regarding Plagiarism

The journal maintains a zero-tolerance policy toward plagiarism, fraud, copyright infringement, or any other violation of publication ethics and copyright laws whether established by relevant legislation or by accepted standards of research and writing. Authors who engage in such practices will receive a formal, stern warning. Furthermore, they may be immediately blacklisted, and/or face other legal actions, depending on the severity and nature of the unethical conduct.

·  Third: Responsibilities of Reviewers/Referees

·  Contribution to Editorial Decisions

The reviewer’s assessment is a vital process that informs editorial decisions regarding the publication of research; it also contributes to the improvement of the work through communication between editors and authors. Peer review is an essential component of formal scholarly work and lies at the heart of the scientific method. The journal maintains that all scholars who wish to contribute to academic publications should, in turn, participate fairly in the review process.

·  Promptness

A reviewer who feels unqualified to assess the research presented in a manuscript, or who anticipates that they will be unable to complete the review in a timely manner, should notify the editor-in-chief and decline the invitation to review.

·  Confidentiality

Manuscripts assigned for review are considered confidential documents. They must not be shown to or discussed with others, except with the explicit permission of the editor.

 

 

·  Standards of Objectivity:

Reviews must be conducted objectively. Personal criticism of the author is inappropriate; reviewers should express their views clearly and support them with reasoned arguments.

·  Reference to Sources

Reviewers should identify relevant published work that the author has failed to cite. Furthermore, any citations, derivations, or arguments drawn from previous research should be accompanied by appropriate references. Furthermore, reviewers should point out any significant similarity or overlap between the proposed research (submitted for publication) and any previously published work of which they are aware.

·  Disclosure of Conflicts of Interest

Reviewers may not use unpublished material disclosed in a manuscript for their own research without the explicit written consent of the author. Information or original ideas obtained through the peer-review process must be kept confidential and not used for personal gain. Additionally, reviewers should refrain from evaluating manuscripts that present a conflict of interest—whether arising from competitive or collaborative relationships, or any other connections with the authors, companies, or institutions involved in the research.